Which NY team has the better QB?

[Snacks]

Boomer and Carton talked about this today.


So who is the better QB, Mark Sanchez NYJ or Eli Manning NYG?

[underdog]

Fitzpatrick.

[Gutter]

1 Super Bowl Ring > 2 AFC Championship losses.

[Snacks]

1 Super Bowl Ring > 2 AFC Championship losses.

Team = something totally different. We are talking about QB not team!

[Crispy_Mobile]

Im with UD. Ny only has 1 team, the Bills. The choices are either Brown or Fitzpatrick. Now if you want to talk about fuckable Jersey QB's gimme Sanchez baby!

[Gutter]

Team = something totally different. We are talking about QB not team!

I still think Eli is the better QB.

[weekapaugjz]

Fitzpatrick.

no he's not. i'd rather have eli or sanchize.

and that's saying a lot.

[TripleSkeet]

1 Super Bowl Ring > 2 AFC Championship losses.

This. Giants fans fucking amaze me. He WON that fucking Super Bowl. As good as your defense played, in the final minutes of the game your team was still LOSING. The game was over and he drove them down the field with some incredible escapes and throws. Yet people will sit here and give Sanchez the nod over him. Even though hes accomplished nothing. Fucking amazing.

[TripleSkeet]

Next time, make it a public poll too. We arent exactly debating abortion over here.

[Gutter]

This. Giants fans fucking amaze me. He WON that fucking Super Bowl. As good as your defense played, in the final minutes of the game your team was still LOSING. The game was over and he drove them down the field with some incredible escapes and throws. Yet people will sit here and give Sanchez the nod over him. Even though hes accomplished nothing. Fucking amazing.

Thank you Trip. Giants win a super bowl and Manning somehow still sucks....granted he had a horrible season this year, but still.....when he got to the big dance, he made it count.

[foodcourtdruide]

Eli, by far. I'm not saying Sanchez may not develop into a better QB. However, if I had to choose a QB for JUST NEXT SEASON, I'm going with Eli without a doubt.