Best NYC Steakhouse

[TheGameHHH]

Ok folks, I've decided that for my birthday this year I'm going to some steakhouse in the city (so I dont wanna hear your opinions about some place in jersey or chicago or california, keep it strictly new york city). Problem is, I don't know where to go. I want the best. I did some preliminary searching online and came up with a few names like Del Frisco's, Sparks, Strip House, Palm and BLT Prime. What are some great steakhouses that all have you have been to? What do you recommend? And please refrain from dropping Lugars into this conversation, its not happening.

[Sinestro]

Can't beat the "Tomahawk" steak from Del Fresco's. Although the "family style" sides are okay but not the family type style portions that you expect in certain restaurants.

[Snoogans]

Sizzler

[johnniehardrock]

The best steak house in NYC if not the countr is Wolfgangs. I have never had a steak that good in my life. I have been to Sparks, Lugers, Mortons, Ruth Chris, Palm, Strip House and they cant even come close to Wolfgangs.
http://www.wolfgangssteakhouse.com/

[Snoogans]

i know my favorite place in the city for high quality beef products is Gray's Papaya

[tele7]

Sizzler

http://images.fanpop.com/images/image_uploads/Happy-Gilmore-adam-sandler-203850_450_370.jpg

[Sinestro]

Burger King Angus Burger. Can't beat flamed broiled.

[weekapaugjz]

Burger King Angus Burger. Can't beat flamed broiled.

fuck that. mcdonalds angus deluxe!

[Snoogans]

fuck that. mcdonalds angus deluxe!

MCDLT bitch

http://www.todayscampus.com/uploads/Remember/mcdlt1.jpg

[weekapaugjz]

i've heard applebee's has some really good steaks.

[Judge Smails]

Beefsteak Charlie's

[Snoogans]

i've heard applebee's has some really good steaks.

i thought someone would do this but with the obvious Outback

Thats why i used sizzler

so did they:
http://nicekicks.com/files/2009/07/white-men-cant-jump-movie-shots-11.png

[weekapaugjz]

gibson's steakhouse in chicago is one of my favorites.

[happytypinggirl]

Wolfgangs is great but its very much like Peter Lugar. Not sure what was the reason you are avoiding Lugars. I'd avoid the striphouse. If you're looking for a steakhouse, I'd have to go with Wolfgangs. If you're looking for where you'll get the best steak, there are a few non-steakhouses that I think have better steaks. Like Bar Americain, or Craft. Angelo and Maxies used to be great but I havent been there in years.

[TheGameHHH]

Wolfgangs is great but its very much like Peter Lugar. Not sure what was the reason you are avoiding Lugars. I'd avoid the striphouse. If you're looking for a steakhouse, I'd have to go with Wolfgangs. If you're looking for where you'll get the best steak, there are a few non-steakhouses that I think have better steaks. Like Bar Americain, or Craft. Angelo and Maxies used to be great but I havent been there in years.

First, thanks. Secondly, my reason for avoiding Lugars is twofold. Ive been there, I want to go somewhere I havent been and I didnt really think it was all that great. Dont get me wrong, it wasnt like the steak sucked but i wasnt as impressed with it as others are.

[TheGameHHH]

The best steak house in NYC if not the countr is Wolfgangs. I have never had a steak that good in my life. I have been to Sparks, Lugers, Mortons, Ruth Chris, Palm, Strip House and they cant even come close to Wolfgangs.
http://www.wolfgangssteakhouse.com/

thanks johnnie. thats moving to the top of my list now

[Snoogans]

thanks johnnie. thats moving to the top of my list now

aight fine, but im tellin you you are missin out

[TheGameHHH]

aight fine, but im tellin you you are missin out

i wish i had the money to hit up Sizzler, but seriously its just too much. I dont wanna go crazy

[Snoogans]

i wish i had the money to hit up Sizzler, but seriously its just too much. I dont wanna go crazy

i meant grays papaya

[razorboy]

i meant grays papaya

Mmmmm. Ratsteak sausages.

[sailor]

First, thanks. Secondly, my reason for avoiding Lugars is twofold. Ive been there, I want to go somewhere I havent been and I didnt really think it was all that great. Dont get me wrong, it wasnt like the steak sucked but i wasnt as impressed with it as others are.

did you get the steak for two? if you get for one, you get scraps pieced together.

[CruelCircus]

In a slightly different direction, I had fantastic steak at this Argentinian steakhouse:

Industria Argentina (http://www.iatribeca.com/index2.htm)

They've got a great wine list, too.

In terms of traditional places, I've heard great things about Old Homestead, but haven't been there myself.

[joethebartender]

Ben Benson's (was there in December and the place still kicks ass).

[MattyIceVA]

Sparks!

[ScottFromGA]

its not in New York, but if your ever heading to Florida or in South Georgia you outta try and find Benton Lee's Steakhouse.

best fucking steaks I've ever had....

http://bentonlees.com/

[Ritalin]

If it was my birthday - which is next Saturday - I'd go to Old Homestead in the Meatpacking, or I'd throw on the coat and tie and eat in the Bar at the 21 Club.

[A.J.]

Outback.

New York - 3rd Ave
(212) 935-6400
919 Third Ave. / 56th St.
New York, NY 10022

New York - 6th Ave/Chelsea
(212) 989-3122
60 W. 23rd Street
New York, NY 10010

[happytypinggirl]

First, thanks. Secondly, my reason for avoiding Lugars is twofold. Ive been there, I want to go somewhere I havent been and I didnt really think it was all that great. Dont get me wrong, it wasnt like the steak sucked but i wasnt as impressed with it as others are.

To be completely honest, Ive been disappointed with most of the well known steakhouses in NYC. I havent tried Ben Bensons though, and always wanted to. :)

[WRESTLINGFAN]

Smith and Wollenskys on 47th and 3rd. A bit pricey but well worth it. Get the seafood tower as an appy

[underdog]

Smith and Wollenskys on 47th and 3rd. A bit pricey but well worth it. Get the seafood tower as an appy

snoogans already suggested sizzler.

[EddieMoscone]

I've been to a few NYC steakhouse (Luger's, Strip House, Sparks, Old Homestead, Uncle Jacks, etc) and my favorite in definitely Keen's. All of the food is great, plus they have a mutton chop which is OUT OF THIS WORLD if you want to mix it up. Service has always been excellent (and friendly).

[Snoogans]

snoogans already suggested sizzler.

charlie browns is another good one. also dave and busters makes a mean strip

[TheGameHHH]

charlie browns is another good one. also dave and busters makes a mean strip

the charlie browns in fairfield used to rock a mean 25 cent wing day on wenesday.