There has never been a good comic book movie.

[lleeder]

I was watching the original X-Men movie last night for the first time in a long time when I came to the realization that it was pure shit. Every comic book movie is about as good as reading 3-4 issues of your favorite book. None of these movies should ever be made. They attempt to cram as much origin as they can into a 2 and half hour time frame and rush a subpar story after the fact. I refuse to watch this shit anymore.

[Snoogans]

V for Vendetta isnt a bad movie. I dont give a fuck what anyone says. I like it. dark knight isnt bad either

[Gvac]

I'm with lleeder.

Although I heard Sin City was a comic book and I love that freaking movie.

[Dirtbag]

I was watching the original X-Men movie last night for the first time in a long time when I came to the realization that it was pure shit. Every comic book movie is about as good as reading 3-4 issues of your favorite book. None of these movies should ever be made. They attempt to cram as much origin as they can into a 2 and half hour time frame and rush a subpar story after the fact. I refuse to watch this shit anymore.
X-Men 2 and Spider-Man 2 are both better than the originals. Never mind that the third parts of both sucked horse cock.

[mikeyboy]

I like American Splendor.

[hammersavage]

mikey's right. Shocker

[dino_electropolis]

V for Vendetta isnt a bad movie. I dont give a fuck what anyone says. I like it. dark knight isnt bad either

Not a bad movie?

That movie fkn rocks.....probably my favorite in the genre.

And so dead on with all the shit thats goin on in the world, more so than say, a movie about flying men with capes.


"Remember remember the 5th of November"

[yojimbo7248]

I like American Splendor.


I'm with you. Does Crumb count?

[Snoogans]

Not a bad movie?

That movie fkn rocks.....probably my favorite in the genre.

And so dead on with all the shit thats goin on in the world, more so than say, a movie about flying men with capes.


"Remember remember the 5th of November"

the gunpowder, treason, and plot. I know of know reason why the gun powder treason should EVER BE FORGOT

[Gvac]

V For Vendetta was awful.

[hammersavage]

Ghost World, Dark Knight, Road to Perdition all good to great films.

[Snoogans]

V For Vendetta was awful.

you need to stop ignoring the nurses and get back in bed, old man

[Gvac]

you need to stop ignoring the nurses and get back in bed, old man

You need to stop smoking so much pot.

You're no longer capable of rational thought.

[Gvac]

And Natalie Portman has less sex appeal than a wooden board.

Less curves, too.

[epo]

And Natalie Portman has less sex appeal than a wooden board.

Less curves, too.

I hate you.

[lleeder]

Read some issues of Batman and you'll realize that Dark Knight is weak.

[Snoogans]

And Natalie Portman has less sex appeal than a wooden board.

Less curves, too.

im not arguing she is hot in that movie. I just like the movie. And the book.

[dino_electropolis]

V For Vendetta was awful.

Wow, first the Jolly Ranchers and now this?

I understand, though, if the plot was a bit much for your geriatric brain....maybe i can sit you down and explain it to you sometime....very, very slowly.

[Gvac]

Wow, first the Jolly Ranchers and now this?

I understand, though, if the plot was a bit much for your geriatric brain....maybe i can sit you down and explain it to you sometime....very, very slowly.

Ha!

The movie blew.

Admit it.

[mikeyboy]

And Natalie Portman has less sex appeal than a wooden board.

Less curves, too.

I agree with Gvac.

Is lleeder right?

[weekapaugjz]

history of violence is a solid movie, but i haven't read the graphic novel, so i don't know how it compares.

[drjoek]

I agree with Gvac.

Is lleeder right?



Lleeder is NEVER right.

[lleeder]

Lleeder is NEVER right.

What about the time I said "drjoek is a sack of shit"? That was never disputed.

[Ritalin]

What about The Ten Commandments?

[drjoek]

What about the time I said "drjoek is a sack of shit"? That was never disputed.



Alright
Even a blind squirrel finds a nut once in a while

[jab]

I like American Splendor.

I'm with you. Does Crumb count?

Ghost World, Dark Knight, Road to Perdition all good to great films.

right.

Read some issues of Batman and you'll realize that Dark Knight is weak.

wrong.

[hammersavage]

Read some issues of Batman and you'll realize that Dark Knight is weak.

But then I'd be reading comics

[jab]

But then I'd be reading comics

do it. DO IT.

[TjM]

I disagree Hellboy was good

[psycho]

I like Sin City, 300, Watchmen, Iron Man, Batman Begins and the the Dark Knight. I think they're all good movies.

[Aqualad]

You're insane. Ghost World, Batman Begins, Dark Knight, Batman Returns, Hellboy, X-Men 2, Spider-Man 2, Superman, Iron Man, Mystery Men, Men In Black, The Crow, Road to Perdition, A History of Violence, Sin City, 300, Blade, 30 Days of Night...all of these were entertaining movies based on comic books.

[psycho]

You're insane. Ghost World, Batman Begins, Dark Knight, Batman Returns, Hellboy, X-Men 2, Spider-Man 2, Superman, Iron Man, Mystery Men, Men In Black, The Crow, Road to Perdition, A History of Violence, Sin City, 300, Blade, 30 Days of Night...all of these were entertaining movies based on comic books.

I would agree with you that non of them are bad movies, but there's only a few that I'll actually re-watch.

I've never seen the Crow or Road to Perdition, I've heard great things about both though, i gotta check them out.

[Tenbatsuzen]

Dark Knight fails on the sole reason of Bale's voice as Batman.

[instrument]

The difference is in the movie being based on a longstanding series or on a 1-shot, graphic novel.

[weekapaugjz]

punisher: war zone may have been the worst comic book movie ever made.

[jab]

The difference is in the movie being based on a longstanding series or on a 1-shot, graphic novel.

the difference in what?

[TripleSkeet]

Read some issues of Batman and you'll realize that Dark Knight is weak.

Ive read plenty of them and I couldnt disagree more.

Dark Knight
Sin City
Spider-Man 2
Ironman
Batman Begins
X-Men 2

All were great comic book movies. Then again if you think they all suck, instead of them stopping making them, how about you stop going to see them?

[Marc with a c]

'graphic novel' has got to be one of the most infuriating terms ever spoken.

[instrument]

the difference in what?

in a comic book movie being good, the ones most people have listed, v for vendetta included were graphic novels not ongoing series.

[jab]

'graphic novel' has got to be one of the most infuriating terms ever spoken.

you are now my favorite person ever.

[jab]

in a comic book movie being good, the ones most people have listed, v for vendetta included were graphic novels not ongoing series.

v for vendetta was a mini series. so was watchmen. these were NOT graphic novels. if you are going to the store and buying them all in one collection, thats what it is. it is a COLLECTION. a trade paperback, as its called.

if you want to talk graphic (ugh) novels, think a contained story. the death of capatin marvel is a graphic novel. that hulk versus thing from back in the day - graphic novel. bride of the demon, gn. the alcoholic - graphic novel. sandman? NOT A GRAPHIC NOVEL.

listen kids, ill snob out here for you. stop calling it a graphic novel to look like youre more mature or hipper than other people. call it what it is, its a comic book. its (at one time anyway) 4 colored sequential art. and its wonderful. :wallbash::wallbash::wallbash::wallbash::wallbash:

[Aqualad]

Speaking of bad superhero movies, that piece of shit "My Super Ex-Girlfriend" was on TV last night. What a piece of shit.

[Foster]

Speaking of bad superhero movies, that piece of shit "My Super Ex-Girlfriend" was on TV last night. What a piece of shit.

that was a comic book?

[instrument]

Fuck dude wish I could get so excited about a post on a board, and why do they call the watchmen a graphic novel if it isn't by your definition?

I was making the case for an ongoing series vs. A "mini series" or whatever your definition for it is.

[TheMojoPin]

v for vendetta was a mini series. so was watchmen. these were NOT graphic novels. if you are going to the store and buying them all in one collection, thats what it is. it is a COLLECTION. a trade paperback, as its called.

if you want to talk graphic (ugh) novels, think a contained story. the death of capatin marvel is a graphic novel. that hulk versus thing from back in the day - graphic novel. bride of the demon, gn. the alcoholic - graphic novel. sandman? NOT A GRAPHIC NOVEL.

listen kids, ill snob out here for you. stop calling it a graphic novel to look like youre more mature or hipper than other people. call it what it is, its a comic book. its (at one time anyway) 4 colored sequential art. and its wonderful. :wallbash::wallbash::wallbash::wallbash::wallbash:

I just call any comic collected in book form a "graphic novel." I don't give a shit calling them "comics" or "comics books" or "trades." It's all the same thing, just different printing techniques.

[Foster's Blackberry]

I don't like the word "movie", it should be "feature presentation"

[Aqualad]

that was a comic book?

I don't think so.

[Donnie Iris]

X-Men 2 and Spider-Man 2 are both better than the originals. Never mind that the third parts of both sucked horse cock.

You're close. All parts of either franchise suck horse cock.

[jab]

Fuck dude wish I could get so excited about a post on a board

that old gag.

I just call any comic collected in book form a "graphic novel." I don't give a shit calling them "comics" or "comics books" or "trades." It's all the same thing, just different printing techniques.

well, yeah of course you can, you can do anything you want. and i can call spaghetti 'wheat spears' and footballs 'throwyballs'. good for you.

I don't like the word "movie", it should be "feature presentation"

will you finish your shit already.

[TheMojoPin]

well, yeah of course you can, you can do anything you want. and i can call spaghetti 'wheat spears' and footballs 'throwyballs'.

That would be creepy and insane.

[mikeyboy]

I'm gonna refer to Mojo as "nutsack".