Who's Better Kurt Warner or Brett Farve?

[lleeder]

Kurt Warner just got his second team to a Superbowl. Brett Farve couldn't get the Jets to the playoffs. They've both won one a piece. This will be Warner's third trip to the Superbowl and Farve's been there twice. They both have been MVP's.

[epo]

Shut up.

[Knowledged_one]

Both are hof'ers

[underdog]

But Brett Favre always looks like he's having so much fun out there!

[K.C.]

Kurt Warner just got his second team to a Superbowl. Brett Farve couldn't get the Jets to the playoffs. They've both won one a piece. This will be Warner's third trip to the Superbowl and Farve's been there twice. They both have been MVP's.

The sheer 'in-your-face Epo'-ness of this thread redeems you, after the 'LeBron as football' player thread from earlier.

Well done.

[Heather 8]

But Brett Favre always looks like he's having so much fun out there!

Well, yeah, being a gunslinger and all.

[underdog]

Favre is such a gun slinger.

[cougarjake13]

well theyre both 1-1 in super bowls


i guess you can say how super bowl 43 turns out decides it



but even before that i'd say warner

[underdog]

Well, yeah, being a gunslinger and all.

Favre is such a gun slinger.

Haha.

[King Hippos Bandaid]

I bet Warner retires with some class


but Favre was better

[razorboy]

Somewhere in heaven Brett Favre's Dad is watching him being a pussy attention whore.

[spoon]

So what's the question Lleeder? Who's better at throwing picks or all around turnovers!? For the first I'd go Farve, the latter Warner.

[disneyspy]

just cuz favre is almost as old as warners wife doesnt really make this thread fair

[spoon]

I bet Warner retires with some class


but Favre was better

But it isn't fair, Teebow and Warner have GOD on their side you know.

[vjr97]

warner had the benefit of playing indoors but he is and will never be the i-n-t miester that favre is.kurt is also going to his 3rd superbowl.close call.good question.

[spoon]

just cuz favre is almost as old as warners wife doesnt really make this thread fair

And Marc wants to fuck them both!

[epo]

well theyre both 1-1 in super bowls


i guess you can say how super bowl 43 turns out decides it



but even before that i'd say warner

Mouth-breather

[cougarjake13]

But it isn't fair, Teebow and Warner have GOD on their side you know.

warner had the benefit of playing indoors but he is and will never be the i-n-t miester that favre is.kurt is also going to his 3rd superbowl.close call.good question.

yeh both the rams and cards were dome teams


guess that afl experience came in handy

[KojiClutch]

It's Favre, hands down. His performance in There's Something About Mary was brilliant, while Warner has never been in a movie.

[cougarjake13]

It's Favre, hands down. His performance in There's Something About Mary was brilliant, while Warner has never been in a movie.

but he was on wheel of fortune

[Sinestro]

Neil Lomax

[cougarjake13]

don majikowski

[KojiClutch]

but he was on wheel of fortuneYeah, but he didn't land Vanna White because he's married to a man-looking woman. Doesn't count.

[Tenbatsuzen]

Warner. Simply because he's led two different teams to Super Bowls. Bringing your own team back to one is hard enough - but different teams? The only person who comes close in the modern era to that is probably Elway, whose SB-winning Broncos teams were radically different than the Reeves-era teams.

The other thing is that Warner has shown leadership qualities that Favre seems to be lacking, especially with the backlash he's been dealing with. You never heard about these personality issues with Warner that you hear with Favre.

The final piece - Warner worked his ASS off to get where he was. Think about this. Warner has played in the AFL, the NFLE, and then the NFL and led two different teams to the Super Bowl. No other QB can claim that.

[Knowledged_one]

don majikowski

i know this guy

[Tenbatsuzen]

Excuse me - the other QB to lead two different teams to the Super Bowl was... Craig Morton?

[cougarjake13]

Warner. Simply because he's led two different teams to Super Bowls. Bringing your own team back to one is hard enough - but different teams? The only person who comes close in the modern era to that is probably Elway, whose SB-winning Broncos teams were radically different than the Reeves-era teams.

The other thing is that Warner has shown leadership qualities that Favre seems to be lacking, especially with the backlash he's been dealing with. You never heard about these personality issues with Warner that you hear with Favre.

The final piece - Warner worked his ASS off to get where he was. Think about this. Warner has played in the AFL, the NFLE, and then the NFL and led two different teams to the Super Bowl. No other QB can claim that.


yeh not unless the panthers ever release delhomme and he does it

[cougarjake13]

Excuse me - the other QB to lead two different teams to the Super Bowl was... Craig Morton?

yep the one and only


til kurt

[Knowledged_one]

Warner. Simply because he's led two different teams to Super Bowls. Bringing your own team back to one is hard enough - but different teams? The only person who comes close in the modern era to that is probably Elway, whose SB-winning Broncos teams were radically different than the Reeves-era teams.

The other thing is that Warner has shown leadership qualities that Favre seems to be lacking, especially with the backlash he's been dealing with. You never heard about these personality issues with Warner that you hear with Favre.

The final piece - Warner worked his ASS off to get where he was. Think about this. Warner has played in the AFL, the NFLE, and then the NFL and led two different teams to the Super Bowl. No other QB can claim that.

the only exception i would say is that all nfl qb's work their ass off to get where they are at, it just took warner more time and places to prove he belonged. Its not like favre came from some big school and was handed a starting job

[disneyspy]

trent dilfer took 3,so please end this line of illogical smartness

[cougarjake13]

trent dilfer took 3,so please end this line of illogical smartness

it was only one there budday

[disneyspy]

well he shouda gone with 3,seattle and tb confuse me

[Tenbatsuzen]

trent dilfer took 3,so please end this line of illogical smartness

...wha? Ravens in 2000-2001. When else?

[Tenbatsuzen]

the only exception i would say is that all nfl qb's work their ass off to get where they are at, it just took warner more time and places to prove he belonged. Its not like favre came from some big school and was handed a starting job

Yes, but Warner had to work his ass off just to get into the League itself.

Francesa was talking about HOF qualifications... he said Faulk is a lock to get in, but Warner needed to get into the Super Bowl this year to lock. That I don't get... Two MVPs, one ring and two SB appearances isn't good enough to get you in?

[Knowledged_one]

And couldnt you argue that tom brady has won superbowls with different styles of offense (similar to what you said about elway)

[K.C.]

Warner. Simply because he's led two different teams to Super Bowls. Bringing your own team back to one is hard enough - but different teams? The only person who comes close in the modern era to that is probably Elway, whose SB-winning Broncos teams were radically different than the Reeves-era teams.

The other thing is that Warner has shown leadership qualities that Favre seems to be lacking, especially with the backlash he's been dealing with. You never heard about these personality issues with Warner that you hear with Favre.

The final piece - Warner worked his ASS off to get where he was. Think about this. Warner has played in the AFL, the NFLE, and then the NFL and led two different teams to the Super Bowl. No other QB can claim that.


See, I would say Warner because Favre is an overrated piece of garbage.

But that's just me.

:sleep:


Warner is maybe the most underrated player of this generation of football players, though. When you really get down to his numbers and accomplishments, there's no question about him being a Hall of Famer.

And he's single-handedly revived two of the WORST franchises in professional football (The Rams were a joke before 1999).

[epo]

Warner. Simply because he's led two different teams to Super Bowls. Bringing your own team back to one is hard enough - but different teams?

By that logic, Craig Morton is also better than Favre. That's just crazy talk.

[KojiClutch]

Yes, but Warner had to work his ass off just to get into the League itself.

Francesa was talking about HOF qualifications... he said Faulk is a lock to get in, but Warner needed to get into the Super Bowl this year to lock. That I don't get... Two MVPs, one ring and two SB appearances isn't good enough to get you in?Sad, isn't it?

[cougarjake13]

well he shouda gone with 3,seattle and tb confuse me

yeh he wasnt on those teams anymore when they went

although he was close with seattle, leaving the year they went but he wasnt the starter anyway

[Knowledged_one]

Yes, but Warner had to work his ass off just to get into the League itself.

Francesa was talking about HOF qualifications... he said Faulk is a lock to get in, but Warner needed to get into the Super Bowl this year to lock. That I don't get... Two MVPs, one ring and two SB appearances isn't good enough to get you in?

your first mistake is listening to anything that fat turd francesa says.

and i understood what you meant about warner just how it was worded struck me as awkward. I take it back matty you do know things about sports and i was wrong

[Tenbatsuzen]

Sad, isn't it?

It's also Francesa. He was comparing Warner to fucking Plunkett.

If Warner has 2 more seasons of 3000 yards, his stats would be on par with Jim Kelly's, a first-ballot inductee.

[Tenbatsuzen]

By that logic, Craig Morton is also better than Favre. That's just crazy talk.

Shit, Craig Mack is better than Favre. Flava in ya ear, holla.

[disneyspy]

fuck i yahoo'd superbowl+qb+2 different teams and it sent me to a rf.net thread that i backed up aikman in,i forgot we already discussed this,heres my sign,some one google image search STUPID

[cougarjake13]

hell morton salt is better than favre

[Sinestro]

It's not Farve's fault his WRs run the wrong routes on his INTs.

[epo]

Shit, Craig Mack is better than Favre. Flava in ya ear, holla.

You are just bitter that the Jets were dumb enough to trade for a retired 39-year old QB who didn't know the playbook or workout all off-season.

If he had stayed retired, this thread wouldn't exist. This might be Lleeder's worst thread ever.

[Tenbatsuzen]

And couldnt you argue that tom brady has won superbowls with different styles of offense (similar to what you said about elway)

As Cassel has shown this season, I'm beginning to think Brady is a product of the Belichick system rather than Brady being a gift from Football Heaven. There's no denying he's a good QB. But it would be interesting to see how Brady would react on a non-Belichick team, although that's not going to happen.

Only reason Patriots didn't make the playoffs is the Jets beating them in OT and they were fucking decimated by injuries.

[Tenbatsuzen]

You are just bitter that the Jets were dumb enough to trade for a retired 39-year old QB who didn't know the playbook or workout all off-season.

If he had stayed retired, this thread wouldn't exist. This might be Lleeder's worst thread ever.

I'm more bitter about saying that the Jets should have drafted Flacco. But does anybody listen to me? No. Instead, they get the old man and a shitty selection of QB's in the draft this year.

The only redeeming thing is going to be if they get Gruden. If they get Gruden, I'll feel a lot better.

[epo]

I'm more bitter about saying that the Jets should have drafted Flacco. But does anybody listen to me? No. Instead, they get the old man and a shitty selection of QB's in the draft this year.

The only redeeming thing is going to be if they get Gruden. If they get Gruden, I'll feel a lot better.

If they get Gruden, they mine as well keep Favre for a year to ease the transition for a young QB.

[Tenbatsuzen]

If they get Gruden, they mine as well keep Favre for a year to ease the transition for a young QB.

I seriously wouldn't mind Gruden and Favre for a year to see what happens. My biggest issue with the Jets HC picks has been constantly hiring guys with no HC experience.

[Tenbatsuzen]

BTW, Ben R. has got to be the fattest fucking QB I've ever seen. he makes Lorezen look skinny. When you're wearing black and still look fat, you're fat.

[cougarjake13]

BTW, Ben R. has got to be the fattest fucking QB I've ever seen. he makes Lorezen look skinny. When you're wearing black and still look fat, you're fat.

my wife just said he same thing

[Tenbatsuzen]

my wife just said he same thing

You allow your wife to talk during football?

[cougarjake13]

You allow your wife to talk during football?

now that she's a football fan and knowledgeable about the game



yes

[Snoogans]

If you mean today, its Warner hands down. Career? It's still Favre

[Judge Smails]

I don't give Warner one iota of credit for anything that he's ever accomplished. Did anyone see the on-field interview as soon as the game was over? He said it himself - he owes everything to Jesus. I guess Jesus had some cash on the Cards today and the Rams back in 2000. Now, if you want to add Jesus to your little poll then I'd vote for him.

[Tenbatsuzen]

http://multimedia.premierespeakers.com/speaker/web/10823.jpg

Damn. Wow.

[K.C.]

I don't give Warner one iota of credit for anything that he's ever accomplished. Did anyone see the on-field interview as soon as the game was over? He said it himself - he owes everything to Jesus. I guess Jesus had some cash on the Cards today and the Rams back in 2000. Now, if you want to add Jesus to your little poll then I'd vote for him.

Damn, Jesus must be awesome against the spread this year.

What's his 900 number?

[Snoogans]

I don't give Warner one iota of credit for anything that he's ever accomplished. Did anyone see the on-field interview as soon as the game was over? He said it himself - he owes everything to Jesus. I guess Jesus had some cash on the Cards today and the Rams back in 2000. Now, if you want to add Jesus to your little poll then I'd vote for him.

He owes alot of it to Larry Fitzgerald and Bruce/Holt also

[Snoogans]

BTW, Ben R. has got to be the fattest fucking QB I've ever seen. he makes Lorezen look skinny. When you're wearing black and still look fat, you're fat.

You have obviously never watched a Raiders game

[Tenbatsuzen]

You have obviously never watched a Raiders game

Guilty. But... can you blame me?

[epo]

He owes alot of it to Larry Fitzgerald and Bruce/Holt also

Fitz could make Rex Grossman look awesome.

[Snoogans]

Guilty. But... can you blame me?

hahaha no, but Jamarcus Russel is a fuckin tank

[Tenbatsuzen]

Fitz could make Rex Grossman look awesome.

Fitz could make Rex MANNING look awesome.

[Friday]

Fitz could make Rex MANNING look awesome.

rex manning IS awesome!

http://bp1.blogger.com/_8bmR4tAmQ4A/Rcf4SI7giRI/AAAAAAAAAIM/iH_8ls7dup0/s320/rex+manning.jpg

[Snoogans]

uh oh, someone let the woman into a sports discussion.

[cougarjake13]

uh oh, someone let the woman into a sports discussion.

what else would you expect from a packers fan

[Tenbatsuzen]

rex manning IS awesome!

http://bp1.blogger.com/_8bmR4tAmQ4A/Rcf4SI7giRI/AAAAAAAAAIM/iH_8ls7dup0/s320/rex+manning.jpg

http://splatterblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/women_internet.jpg

[TripleSkeet]

Warner. Definitely.